Snow Blowing vs Snow Plowing: A Comparison of Snow Removal Methods

When winter brings heavy snowfall, the choice of how to clear the snow becomes crucial for safety and convenience. Two popular methods for snow removal are snow blowing and snow plowing. Both techniques serve the same purpose of clearing snow from driveways, roads, and other areas, but they have different approaches and benefits. Here are the key differences between snow blowing and snow plowing:

1. Method of Snow Removal

  • Snow Blowing: A snow blower uses a powerful auger and fan system to suck up snow from the ground and propel it through a chute to be tossed away. This method is ideal for lighter, powdery snow and is commonly used for smaller areas like driveways, sidewalks, and walkways.

  • Snow Plowing: A snow plow, typically mounted on a truck or tractor, pushes the snow off the surface using a large, angled blade. It works well for larger areas such as roads, parking lots, and driveways, especially when snow is more compact or heavy.

2. Efficiency and Speed

  • Snow Blowing: Snow blowers are generally slower compared to plows since they are designed for more detailed work, like clearing walkways or small driveways. However, they excel in precision and can clear snow from hard-to-reach places with ease.

  • Snow Plowing: Snow plows are faster, as they can cover a wider area in a shorter amount of time. They are ideal for clearing large stretches of roadways or open spaces quickly but are less precise in areas with tight corners or obstacles.

3. Suitability for Snow Conditions

  • Snow Blowing: Snow blowers are more effective for lighter, fluffier snow. They may struggle with heavy, wet, or packed snow, which can clog the machine or make the clearing process slower.

  • Snow Plowing: Snow plows are better equipped to handle heavier snowfalls and packed snow. They work by pushing the snow aside, so even wet, dense snow can be moved relatively easily.

4. Maintenance and Operation

  • Snow Blowing: Snow blowers are smaller, more maneuverable, and easier to store. However, they require regular maintenance, such as checking the auger and belts, especially if used frequently or in harsh conditions. They are also more labor-intensive and require physical effort, especially for larger driveways.

  • Snow Plowing: Snow plows, typically attached to trucks or tractors, require more maintenance, particularly for the vehicle itself. The blades may need sharpening or replacing after extended use. Operation tends to be less physically demanding since it’s vehicle-based, but handling the equipment may require more skill.

5. Cost

  • Snow Blowing: Snow blowers are generally more affordable compared to snow plows, making them a better option for homeowners who want to clear small to medium-sized areas. While some high-end models can be expensive, they are typically a one-time purchase.

  • Snow Plowing: Snow plows are more expensive due to the cost of the vehicle and the plow attachment. This makes them a better option for larger properties or commercial applications, where snow removal needs are extensive.

Conclusion:

Both snow blowing and snow plowing offer distinct advantages depending on the job at hand. Snow blowers are ideal for smaller, residential spaces with lighter snowfalls, offering precision and ease of use. Snow plows, on the other hand, excel in clearing larger areas with heavier snow and are more efficient for commercial properties or roads. Understanding the specific needs of your space and the type of snow you are dealing with can help you choose the right tool for the job.